top of page

Another Debate with a Globie

So I have an old friend who seems to believe the Sea is Level but the Earth is still curved. Recently, he sent me a clip entitled the "Happy tourist from Netherlands flys to the Edge of Space" in a Russian MIG-29, back in in September 2015. This fellow seems to believe that it's necessary to travel higher that the average commercial jet before the Earth's alleged curvature reveals itself. The chatter between the MIG pilot and the Dutch tourist in the clip reveals their highest point during the flight to be 14 kilometres, which is 45,920 feet (14,000 x 3.28), or about 10-12,000 feet higher than the average commercial jet. You can watch the clip below -- the best views of the Earth's horizon start about Minute 7 :

I watched the clip closely, knowing fell well what I would see, and captured a couple of screenshots, from 14 kilometers high. I returned the images to my friend and thanked him for proving making my case, and proving that all real photos of the horizon reveal horizontal, like the Sea. Here are the two best shots which clearly reveal a flat horizon (hold a ruler or straight edge to it):

My friend did the same, and then returned this screenshot to me ...

... to which I replied with this image, below, and added that he should google up what is a "fish eye" lens and how it works!

I then reminded him of Chris Hadfield's photo below, from his book, to which Chris claims was taken during his (alleged) journey from Earth to the International Space Station:

My friend looked responded that there appears to be a "slight curve" in the Hadfield photo?

I suggested he look again, and this time with his glasses on! I also reminded him that from this elevation (my estimate) of 150,000 feet, the photo reveals approximately 200 miles of horizon, and that according to his globe model (3959 mile radius) there is supposed to be 26,332 feet of curvature at this distance , or just under 5 miles.

The debate was gone quiet for the moment ...

207 views5 comments

Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page